Automated Reasoning in Artificial Intelligence

Author

Your Name

Published

February 5, 2025

Introduction

This document introduces the course “Automated Reasoning” (ragionamento automatico), emphasizing its significance within the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI). The course will be conducted in English.

A notable change from previous years is the modification of the exam format. Due to the increased number of students, the traditional post-exam project will be adjusted. The updated format is detailed in the course syllabus.

The primary goal of this introduction is to explore the rationale behind including automated reasoning in an AI curriculum. We are increasingly reliant on technology for tasks that previously required human thought and memory. Search engines and AI tools like ChatGPT have made it appear that active learning and memorization are becoming obsolete. This shift raises questions about the role of education and the importance of retaining knowledge.

For instance, the ability to recall information, such as phone numbers, has diminished as we rely on devices to store this data. This trend extends to more complex domains as well. For example, AI systems are being developed to assist in legal decision-making, potentially replacing human lawyers in some tasks.

However, the limitations of current AI are evident. Historical examples, such as the Soviet Luna mission in 1959 and the Apollo 11 mission in 1969, demonstrate that significant technological achievements were possible without AI. In contrast, recent AI-driven projects, like SpaceX’s missile launch and Japan’s space probe, have encountered significant challenges. These examples highlight that AI, in its current state, may not be as reliable or advanced as some believe.

The concerns about the overreliance on AI are not new. Geoffrey Hinton, a pioneer in deep learning, recently left Google due to ethical concerns about the technology’s development and potential misuse. He expressed concerns about the safety of using AI for prediction.

The Turing Test, introduced by Alan Turing in his 1950 paper “Computing Machinery and Intelligence”, is a foundational concept in AI. The test proposes that a machine can be considered intelligent if it can convincingly imitate a human in a conversation, specifically by imitating a human who is lying. This highlights the complexity of creating AI that can not only provide correct answers but also mimic human-like deception.

In 1955, John McCarthy defined AI as “the science and engineering of making intelligent machines.” This definition emphasizes the interdisciplinary nature of AI, requiring collaboration between computer scientists and engineers. McCarthy’s vision of “strong AI” involves creating machines that can perform tasks that would require intelligence if done by humans. This includes seemingly simple tasks, like providing directions, which are often accomplished by algorithms that predate modern AI.

The Dartmouth Summer Research Project on Artificial Intelligence in 1956 brought together leading AI researchers to discuss the future of the field. The debates and predictions made then are still relevant today, highlighting the enduring challenges and aspirations of AI research.

Historical Context of AI

Early Achievements Without AI

1959: The Soviet Union’s Luna mission successfully reached the moon without the use of AI. This achievement was made possible through human ingenuity and engineering.
1969: The Apollo 11 mission landed humans on the moon, also without AI. This landmark event demonstrated the capabilities of human-driven technological advancement.

Recent AI Challenges

SpaceX Missile Launch (Last Year): An AI-driven project by SpaceX resulted in a missile being destroyed shortly after launch. This incident highlights the potential risks and failures of current AI systems.
Japan’s Space Probe (2023): An AI project in Japan led to a miscalculation in the attitude of a spacecraft, resulting in a loss of contact. This further underscores the limitations of AI in complex, real-world applications.

Key Figures and Concepts in AI

Geoffrey Hinton and Concerns about AI

Geoffrey Hinton, a key figure in deep learning, expressed concerns about the direction of AI development. He quit Google, stating that AI prediction tools cannot be used safely. This highlights the ethical considerations and potential risks associated with advanced AI technologies.

The Turing Test

The Turing Test, introduced by Alan Turing in 1950, is a test of a machine’s ability to exhibit intelligent behavior equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, that of a human. The test involves a machine imitating a human who is lying, adding a layer of complexity to the challenge.

Imitation Game: Turing proposed that a machine is intelligent if it can play the role of A (a male) in the imitation game, where A and B (a female) answer questions from C, who must determine their genders. A lies while B tells the truth.
Complexity of Deception: Turing’s test highlights the difficulty of creating AI that can mimic human-like deception, as opposed to simply accessing and providing correct information. This requires a deeper level of understanding and manipulation of language.

McCarthy’s Definition of AI

In 1955, John McCarthy defined AI as “the science and engineering of making intelligent machines.” This definition underscores the need for both scientific research and engineering to create machines that can perform tasks requiring human intelligence.

The Dartmouth Summer Research Project

The 1956 Dartmouth Summer Research Project, considered the birthplace of AI, brought together leading AI researchers, including McCarthy, Minsky, and Claude Shannon, to set the research agenda for AI. The discussions and debates from this event remain relevant to contemporary AI research.

Claude Shannon: The father of information theory, whose work will be covered in this course.
Note: The transcript lacks specific details about the contributions or discussions that took place at the Dartmouth conference. Further information on this topic will be provided in subsequent lectures.

Conclusion

This lecture has provided an introduction to the course on Automated Reasoning and its significance within the broader field of Artificial Intelligence. We have explored the historical context of AI, highlighting both the achievements made without AI and the recent challenges faced by AI-driven projects.

Key concepts such as the Turing Test and McCarthy’s definition of AI have been introduced, along with the concerns raised by pioneers like Geoffrey Hinton. The interdisciplinary nature of AI, requiring collaboration between computer science and engineering, has been emphasized.

The enduring relevance of the discussions from the 1956 Dartmouth Summer Research Project underscores the ongoing challenges and aspirations in AI research. As we move forward, it is crucial to critically evaluate the capabilities and limitations of AI, ensuring that we do not become overly reliant on technology at the expense of human knowledge and critical thinking.

The format of the exam has been adjusted due to the increased number of students.
Current AI systems have limitations, as evidenced by recent project failures.
The Turing Test highlights the complexity of creating AI that can mimic human-like deception.
AI requires an interdisciplinary approach, combining computer science and engineering.

How can we ensure the safe and ethical development of AI?
What are the specific limitations of current AI systems, and how can they be addressed?
What role should human knowledge and critical thinking play in an increasingly AI-driven world?
What were the specific contributions and discussions from the Dartmouth Summer Research Project, and how are they relevant today?
Suggestion: Explore the concept of “ingannevole” (deceptive) in the context of AI and the Turing Test.

--- title: "Automated Reasoning in Artificial Intelligence" author: "Your Name" date: "2025-02-05" format: html: toc: true # Table of Contents toc-depth: 2 code-tools: true theme: cosmo # Or "journal" for Distill-like minimalism --- # Introduction {#sec:introduction} ::: tcolorbox This document introduces the course *"Automated Reasoning"* (*ragionamento automatico*), emphasizing its significance within the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI). The course will be conducted in English. ::: ::: tcolorbox A notable change from previous years is the modification of the exam format. Due to the increased number of students, the traditional post-exam project will be adjusted. The updated format is detailed in the course syllabus. ::: The primary goal of this introduction is to explore the rationale behind including automated reasoning in an AI curriculum. We are increasingly reliant on technology for tasks that previously required human thought and memory. Search engines and AI tools like ChatGPT have made it appear that active learning and memorization are becoming obsolete. This shift raises questions about the role of education and the importance of retaining knowledge. For instance, the ability to recall information, such as phone numbers, has diminished as we rely on devices to store this data. This trend extends to more complex domains as well. For example, AI systems are being developed to assist in legal decision-making, potentially replacing human lawyers in some tasks. However, the limitations of current AI are evident. Historical examples, such as the Soviet *Luna* mission in 1959 and the *Apollo 11* mission in 1969, demonstrate that significant technological achievements were possible without AI. In contrast, recent AI-driven projects, like SpaceX's missile launch and Japan's space probe, have encountered significant challenges. These examples highlight that AI, in its current state, may not be as reliable or advanced as some believe. The concerns about the overreliance on AI are not new. [Geoffrey Hinton](#subsec:geoffrey_hinton), a pioneer in deep learning, recently left Google due to ethical concerns about the technology's development and potential misuse. He expressed concerns about the safety of using AI for prediction. The [Turing Test](#subsec:turing_test), introduced by Alan Turing in his 1950 paper *"Computing Machinery and Intelligence"*, is a foundational concept in AI. The test proposes that a machine can be considered intelligent if it can convincingly imitate a human in a conversation, specifically by imitating a human who is lying. This highlights the complexity of creating AI that can not only provide correct answers but also mimic human-like deception. In 1955, [John McCarthy](#subsec:mccarthy_definition) defined AI as *"the science and engineering of making intelligent machines."* This definition emphasizes the interdisciplinary nature of AI, requiring collaboration between computer scientists and engineers. McCarthy's vision of *"strong AI"* involves creating machines that can perform tasks that would require intelligence if done by humans. This includes seemingly simple tasks, like providing directions, which are often accomplished by algorithms that predate modern AI. The Dartmouth Summer Research Project on Artificial Intelligence in 1956 brought together leading AI researchers to discuss the future of the field. The debates and predictions made then are still relevant today, highlighting the enduring challenges and aspirations of AI research. # Historical Context of AI {#sec:historical_context} ## Early Achievements Without AI {#subsec:early_achievements} - **1959**: The Soviet Union's *Luna* mission successfully reached the moon without the use of AI. This achievement was made possible through human ingenuity and engineering. - **1969**: The *Apollo 11* mission landed humans on the moon, also without AI. This landmark event demonstrated the capabilities of human-driven technological advancement. ## Recent AI Challenges {#subsec:recent_ai_challenges} - **SpaceX Missile Launch (Last Year)**: An AI-driven project by SpaceX resulted in a missile being destroyed shortly after launch. This incident highlights the potential risks and failures of current AI systems. - **Japan's Space Probe (2023)**: An AI project in Japan led to a miscalculation in the attitude of a spacecraft, resulting in a loss of contact. This further underscores the limitations of AI in complex, real-world applications. # Key Figures and Concepts in AI {#sec:key_figures_concepts} ## Geoffrey Hinton and Concerns about AI {#subsec:geoffrey_hinton} ::: tcolorbox **Geoffrey Hinton**, a key figure in deep learning, expressed concerns about the direction of AI development. He quit Google, stating that AI prediction tools cannot be used safely. This highlights the ethical considerations and potential risks associated with advanced AI technologies. ::: ## The Turing Test {#subsec:turing_test} ::: tcolorbox The **Turing Test**, introduced by Alan Turing in 1950, is a test of a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent behavior equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, that of a human. The test involves a machine imitating a human who is lying, adding a layer of complexity to the challenge. ::: - **Imitation Game**: Turing proposed that a machine is intelligent if it can play the role of A (a male) in the imitation game, where A and B (a female) answer questions from C, who must determine their genders. A lies while B tells the truth. - **Complexity of Deception**: Turing's test highlights the difficulty of creating AI that can mimic human-like deception, as opposed to simply accessing and providing correct information. This requires a deeper level of understanding and manipulation of language. ## McCarthy's Definition of AI {#subsec:mccarthy_definition} ::: tcolorbox In 1955, **John McCarthy** defined AI as *"the science and engineering of making intelligent machines."* This definition underscores the need for both scientific research and engineering to create machines that can perform tasks requiring human intelligence. ::: ## The Dartmouth Summer Research Project {#subsec:dartmouth_project} ::: tcolorbox The 1956 Dartmouth Summer Research Project, considered the birthplace of AI, brought together leading AI researchers, including McCarthy, Minsky, and Claude Shannon, to set the research agenda for AI. The discussions and debates from this event remain relevant to contemporary AI research. ::: - **Claude Shannon**: The father of information theory, whose work will be covered in this course. - **Note**: The transcript lacks specific details about the contributions or discussions that took place at the Dartmouth conference. Further information on this topic will be provided in subsequent lectures. # Conclusion {#sec:conclusion} This lecture has provided an introduction to the course on Automated Reasoning and its significance within the broader field of Artificial Intelligence. We have explored the historical context of AI, highlighting both the achievements made without AI and the recent challenges faced by AI-driven projects. Key concepts such as the [Turing Test](#subsec:turing_test) and [McCarthy's definition of AI](#subsec:mccarthy_definition) have been introduced, along with the concerns raised by pioneers like [Geoffrey Hinton](#subsec:geoffrey_hinton). The interdisciplinary nature of AI, requiring collaboration between computer science and engineering, has been emphasized. The enduring relevance of the discussions from the [1956 Dartmouth Summer Research Project](#subsec:dartmouth_project) underscores the ongoing challenges and aspirations in AI research. As we move forward, it is crucial to critically evaluate the capabilities and limitations of AI, ensuring that we do not become overly reliant on technology at the expense of human knowledge and critical thinking. ::: tcolorbox - The format of the exam has been adjusted due to the increased number of students. - Current AI systems have limitations, as evidenced by recent project failures. - The Turing Test highlights the complexity of creating AI that can mimic human-like deception. - AI requires an interdisciplinary approach, combining computer science and engineering. ::: ::: tcolorbox - How can we ensure the safe and ethical development of AI? - What are the specific limitations of current AI systems, and how can they be addressed? - What role should human knowledge and critical thinking play in an increasingly AI-driven world? - What were the specific contributions and discussions from the Dartmouth Summer Research Project, and how are they relevant today? - **Suggestion**: Explore the concept of *"ingannevole"* (deceptive) in the context of AI and the Turing Test. :::